Rúben Amorim’s Manchester United travel to the City Ground on Tuesday, 1 April, to face Nuno Espírito Santo’s high-flying Nottingham Forest.
This isn’t a new rivalry. It began back in 2010, when Rúben Amorim — then a Benfica midfielder — scored past Nuno Espírito Santo, Porto’s goalkeeper, in the Portuguese League Cup final.
Benfica won 3-0. Fourteen years later, the setting has changed — but the protagonists return. Now, from the touchline.
Both have risen from players to top-flight managers. Both made their names in Portugal. And both now stand at the helm of Premier League projects heading in very different directions.
They share more than a passport. Each has built teams that reflect their values — structure, clarity, and total buy-in. But the football they produce couldn’t be more different.
Pressing, possession and the space in between
Amorim has brought a clear idea to Manchester United. He wants fluidity in possession and aggression out of it. His 3-4-2-1 demands high pressing, rotations between the lines, and technical quality on the ball. It’s a system built on overloads, control, and attacking shape.
But it hasn’t always landed. Injuries, inconsistent availability, and a mismatched squad have made the transition messy. Still, the identity is visible in glimpses. When United do get it right — like in the 3-0 win over Leicester City — they look like a team finally starting to understand the plan.
Espírito Santo’s Nottingham Forest, by contrast, are a team that already knows exactly who they are. They don’t want the ball. They want the space behind you. Forest rank second-lowest in possession, yet sit third in the table.
They defend deep. Then, break with speed and purpose. Their 875 clearances are the most in the league. So are their 11.5 goals over expected — a sign of clinical finishing and smart shot selection. When Forest shoot, it matters.
United, on the other hand, have the opposite problem. One of the highest possession shares in the league but one of the worst xG underperformances. They simply aren’t taking their chances.
Control With vs Without the Ball
Amorim wants United to control the tempo. But right now, Forest look more in control without the ball. Their structure is clear. Their execution, efficient.
Amorim is still mid-build. He’s laid the tactical foundations. Players are starting to return. There’s a framework, but it’s still developing.
Espírito Santo’s squad, on the other hand, have settled into theirs. The roles are understood. The plan is working. It might not be flashy, but it’s effective.
Both managers lean on structure. Both trust systems to shape performance. But the way they go about it — and the way their teams execute it — couldn’t feel more different.
Make sure to follow UtdDistrict on X, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, and TikTok to never miss out on any of our Manchester United content. Our podcast, What the Devil?, is streamed live every Thursday at 12:30 pm (BST) on the United View YouTube channel.